Updated · GarageCue Editorial Team

How to choose a car parts retailer

Compare online car parts shops on vehicle search, the part ranges they carry, return windows, warranty and the ways you can reach support.

What a car parts retailer is for

Online parts shops sell the service and repair parts a car needs over its life: filters, brakes, suspension, lighting, electrical parts and body panels. Some carry a very wide range for many makes. Others focus on one area, such as off-road kit or performance parts. A good shop helps you find the right part for your exact car and makes it easy to send back the wrong one.

You will also see parts from different sources. Genuine parts come from the car maker. Parts from the companies that supply the car maker are often sold under their own names. Aftermarket parts are made by other firms and vary from excellent to poor. Know which kind a listing offers before you compare.

Matching the part to your car

The main risk in buying parts online is getting a part that does not fit. Cars of the same model can use different brakes, sensors or filters depending on the engine, year and trim. A search by vehicle, using your registration or model details, narrows the list. Where you can, compare the part number on the old part with the one in the listing.

The VIN, the vehicle identification number on your papers, is the surest way to identify the car. If a listing is unclear, ask the shop to confirm fitment before you pay, and keep that answer in writing.

Range and the kind of parts you need

Think about what you buy most. A home mechanic doing routine servicing needs filters, brake parts and service items. A restorer needs classic parts that main dealers no longer stock. An off-roader needs suspension, protection and recovery gear. A shop that covers your area well spares you split orders and extra delivery waits.

How the retailers differ

GSTP Auto Parts sells in the US with a search by vehicle and a wide spread of categories, from exhausts and engine parts to brakes, body parts and lighting. It has traded since 2014 and offers email, chat and a help centre.

AutoPartsToys, a US store since 2007, leans toward 4x4 kit, lighting and suspension, and also stocks classic car parts. It lists phone support as well as email and a help centre.

ISOTIGER is a French business founded in 1976 that sells service, engine and electrical parts in France, the US and Canada, with click and collect. A-Premium focuses on brakes and engine parts in the US and gives a warranty of one to three years depending on the product.

Returns, warranty and support

Return windows differ. GSTP Auto Parts and AutoPartsToys allow 30 days, ISOTIGER allows 60 days and A-Premium allows 90 days. Electrical parts are often not returnable once fitted, and opened packaging can affect a refund, so read the terms before you start work.

A warranty matters for parts that can fail early, such as pumps, sensors and starter motors. Keep the receipt and the box. Check how you reach support when a part is wrong: chat and phone are quicker than email when the car is on axle stands.

What to check before you order

Check that the shop ships to your country and how long delivery takes, since a car off the road costs you time. Ask whether old parts must be sent back under an exchange scheme, check who pays for return postage and confirm what proof of fitment the shop accepts if a part turns out to be wrong.

For safety parts such as brakes, steering and suspension, buy from a source you trust and check that the part is marked for your car. If a job is beyond your tools or skills, ask a garage whether it will fit parts you supply, and how it handles a warranty claim on them.

How to shortlist

Note your car’s details and the parts you buy most. Keep shops that sell in your country, cover your parts area and offer a search by vehicle. Compare return windows, warranty and support, then read the reviews. The car parts retailers comparison sets them side by side.

See the full ranking: Top car parts retailers compared →

Sources